Research Article |
Corresponding author: Janakiraman Poorani ( pooranij@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Dominique Zimmermann
© 2019 Kaniyarikkal D. Prathapan, Janakiraman Poorani, S. Amritha Kumari, C. Anuradha, Balakrishnan Padmanaban, Ramalingam Thanigairaj.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Prathapan KD, Poorani J, Amritha Kumari S, Anuradha C, Padmanaban B, Thanigairaj R (2019) Species composition and diagnoses of leaf- and fruit-scarring beetles (Coleoptera, Chrysomelidae) infesting bananas and plantains (Zingiberales, Musaceae) in the Indian subcontinent. Deutsche Entomologische Zeitschrift 66(2): 179-202. https://doi.org/10.3897/dez.66.47447
|
Leaf- and fruit-feeding chrysomelids (Coleoptera) on bananas and plantains (Musaceae, Zingiberales) cause major losses to banana growers in the northern and northeastern regions of India, Bangladesh, and other parts of Southeast Asia. The species composition of these beetles has not been studied so far in India and wrong names or wrong name combinations in the literature have caused confusion. Most particularly, the Central and South American apecies of Colaspis hypochlora Lefèvre (Chrysomelidae, Eumolpinae) has been erroneously reported as occurring in India and Bangladesh, and this name has been used for the Indian species. Based on extensive surveys for leaf- and fruit-feeding chrysomelids in the northern and northeastern regions of India from 2015 to 2019, three species of banana-feeding chrysomelids, namely, Basilepta subcostata (Jacoby) (Eumolpinae), Bhamoina varipes (Jacoby), and a new species, Sphaeroderma cruenta sp. nov. (Galerucinae, Alticini), are documented. Of these, the latter two are recorded as pests of banana in India for the first time. An illustrated diagnostic account of these three species is given to facilitate their identification by economic entomologists. COI sequences of populations of B. subcostata from Assam and Uttar Pradesh showed 98–100% homology, indicating that these populations are conspecific and that COI sequences can be used for rapid species determination. Brief notes on the biology and available management options for these pests are also given.
COI sequences, leaf beetles, Sphaeroderma cruenta sp. nov., new records, South Asia, pest management
India is one of the major centres of diversity for bananas and plantains (Zingiberales, Musaceae) and the largest producer of bananas in the world, with its annual production greater than what the rest of the world produces for export (
At present, there is no systematic study on the species composition of leaf and fruit feeding chrysomelids from the Indian subcontinent.
In South and Southeast Asia, three of the 24 chrysomelid genera on Musaceae are known to feed on banana (
Despite its economic importance, the nomenclature has not been clarified and incorrect names have been used for this species in literature. Indian workers have erroneously applied the name “Colaspis hypochlora” to the Indian scarring beetles (e.g.
The aim of this study is a) to determine the species composition of leaf- and fruit-scarring beetles infesting bananas and plantains in the Indian subcontinent, b) to describe or redescribe these species, and c) to provide a determination key facilitating their correct identification. In this way, we hope to provide a basis for a reliable identification of the banana-feeding chrysomelids, which is needed for species-specific, effective pest management strategies in future.
Surveys were carried out over a period of five years (2015–2019) for banana-feeding chrysomelids in seven states of India, namely, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Assam, Manipur, Meghalaya, West Bengal, and Odisha. Banana fruit-scarring beetles are major pests in the states surveyed (unpublished data from All India Co-ordinated Research Project on Fruits, operated by the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR), New Delhi).
Morphological terminology follows
The endophallus was everted using a KK-3 type C fine nozzle as follows. The endophallus was pushed towards the apical opening using the blunt end of a flexible fine needle through the basal opening and the tip of the fine nozzle, filled with K-Y gel, and affixed at the base of the aedeagus proper with a cyanoacrylate glue (Fevikwik). The assembly was allowed to dry for 5 min. and kept in water for 1 min. to relax the endophallic membrane. Then the aedeagus was immersed in K-Y gel on a glass slide and the endophallus was everted under controlled pressure of a syringe filled with K-Y gel.
Photographs of whole specimens and their diagnostic characters were taken using a Leica M205A stereo microscope fitted with a Leica DMC 4500 digital camera. Image stacks were processed into composite, high resolution images using CombineZP software. Types of Basilepta spp. at the Natural History Museum, London, were studied and photographed with a Canon EOS 1500D DSLR camera fitted with a Canon MP-E 65 mm macrolens and processed with Helicon Focus Pro.
Sequencing of a 660-base pair (bp) fragment of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 (COI) was done for samples of B. subcostata from Assam and Uttar Pradesh. Morphologically identified specimens were used for extraction, amplification and sequencing of 5′ end of COI mtDNA. Genomic DNA was extracted using QiagenDNeasy kit, following the manufacturer’s protocols using the following primers: forward primer (LCO 1490 5′-GGTCAACAAATCATAAAGATATTGG-3′), and reverse primer (HCO 2198 5′- TAAACTTCAGGGTGACCAAAAAATCA-3′). Amplified products were sequenced using Sanger technology and the sequences were submitted to GenBank and accession numbers obtained.
Sequence identity matrix and alignment of COI sequences of B. subcostata from Assam and Uttar Pradesh were executed using the CLUSTAL W multiple alignment tool of BioEdit sequence alignment editor 7.0.5.3. Phylogenetic analysis was performed using the Maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree construct in MEGA X. Sequences of Basilepta leechi (MN343857), B. variable (MN344143), Eumolpinae sp. (KF946194), Chrysomelidae (MK083043), Oryctes rhinoceros (L.) (KP898260), and Coccinella septempunctata L. (MH976795) from GenBank were used for phylogenetic analysis with the last two forming outgroup taxa.
The specimens studied are deposited in the following collections:
ICAR-NBAIR ICAR-National Bureau of Agricultural Insect Resources, Bangalore, India
KAU Travancore Insect Collection, Kerala Agricultural University, Vellayani
ICAR-NRCB ICAR-National Research Centre for Banana, Tiruchirappalli, India
About 1200 specimens of leaf and fruit feeding chrysomelids were collected on banana from seven states of India. The genera and species were identified by the keys given by
Nodostoma subcostatum
Jacoby, 1889:
Nodostoma cyanipenne:
Basilepta subcostatum:
Basilepta subcostata:
Type material
: syntype female, “SYNTYPE (blue bordered circular label)/ Bhamὀ, Birmania, Fea, VII.1886/ Jacoby Coll. 1909-28a/ Nodostoma subcostatum Jac./ abdomen missing, S.L. Shute 1976/NHMUK014016383” (
Body oblong; head mildly sulcate above eyes; antennae filiform or distal antennomeres widened; pronotum wider than long, widest posteriorly, lateral margins often angulate; anterior margin of proepisternum concave; legs long, all femora dilated, minutely dentate ventrally, tibia longitudinally sulcate with a sharp ridge along dorsal side; intermediate and posterior tibiae emarginated preapically; metatibia with a pair of short apical spines; prosternum broader than long. Claws appendiculate; bursa sclerites present in female genitalia.
Basilepta makiharai Kimoto, described from Nepal, is stated to “resemble B. subcostata in having the elytron with humeral ridge but differs by its shorter body length and in having the surface of vertex finely shagreened” (
Nodostoma obscurum Jacoby, 1908 and Basilepta sakaii Takizawa, 1987 were listed as synonyms of B. subcostata in the catalogue of Nepalese Chrysomelidae by
Length 2.34–3.00 mm, width 1.36–1.86 mm, 1.6–1.7× longer than broad. Body (Fig.
Three major color morphs and their intermediates were commonly observed:
Head (Fig.
Compound eyes with inner margin feebly emarginate, transverse diameter about 1.4–1.5× vertical. Distance between eyes 1.8× distance between antennal sockets, shortest distance between compound eye to adjacent antennal socket about 3.5× distance between antennal sockets. Mandibles with two large denticles; maxillary palpi three-segmented excluding palpifer; last palpomere longest, penultimate palpomere less than half length of last palpomere. Labial palpi with three palpomeres, excluding palpiger, first palpomere being shortest and last longest.
Pronotum (Fig.
Prosternum broader than long, broader posteriorly than anteriorly, with bold punctures, posterior margin straight; mesosternum nearly twice as broad as long with a few punctures smaller than those on prosternum. Proepisternum depressed; hypomeron with bold punctures. Legs long; all femora dilated, minutely dentate ventrally beyond middle (Fig.
Ventrites sparsely punctate, pubescent; first ventrite medially longer than following two combined, ventrites 3 and 4 subequal, shorter than 2 and 5 separately which are subequal, last ventrite hardly sexually dimorphic, last tergite without longitudinal groove medially.
Male genitalia: aedeagus in lateral view (Fig.
Endophallus (Fig.
Endophallus of Basilepta subcostata (Jacoby). a. Endophallus completely everted, lateral view; b. Basal phallomere and central sclerite, dorsal view; c. Median phallomere, lateral view; d. Apical phallomere, dorsolateral view. Abbreviations: BP = Basal phallomere; MP = Median Phallomere; AP = Apical phallomere; CS = Central Sclerite.
Female genitalia (Fig.
Female genitalia of Basilepta subcostata (Jacoby). a, b. Spermatheca; c. Bursa copulatrix; d. Ovipositor; e. Eighth sternite and tignum; f. Eighth sternite and 8th ventrite along with tignum; g. Female genitalia. Abbreviations: SpG = spermathecal gland; SpC = spermathecal capsule; SpD = spermathecal duct; MdO = median oviduct; BC = Bursa copulatrix; BS = bursa sclerite; Vg = vagina; CoG = collateral gland; Tg = tignum; ovi = ovipositor.
India [Karnataka (new record); Delhi (
Musa spp. (Musa sapientum, M. acuminata; Musaceae, Zingiberales) are principal hosts. Beetles were observed feeding on ginger (Zingiber officinale Roscoe; Zingiberaceae, Zingiberales) in Meghalaya (D.M. Firake, personal communication). In Assam, northeastern India, adult beetles were observed feeding on Canna indica L. (Cannaceae, Zingiberales) and turmeric (Curcuma longa L., Zingiberaceae) and characteristic feeding marks were observed on the latter. This is the first documentation of other hosts of B. subcostata besides banana. Adults were also found to be resting on taro (Colocasia sp., Araceae, Arales) (unpublished data).
The adult beetles are most active during the monsoon and post-monsoon seasons and summer. They are nocturnal and usually found hiding inside the leaf whorls and come out only when disturbed. They feed on the young unfurled leaves (Fig.
Eggs are laid in the soil and the larvae feed on the roots of grasses and other weeds. Pupation takes place in the soil. Emerging adults feed on young leaves and fruits. Adults hibernate during winter. Seasonal incidence and population dynamics of fruit scarring beetles have been studied from some parts of India, including Assam (
In Uttar Pradesh, North India, adults of the predatory beetle, Paederus fuscipes Curtis (Coleoptera, Staphylinidae), were found to be commonly associated with B. subcostata. Natural epizootics of entomofungal pathogens, such as Beauveria bassiana, are commonly observed on B. subcostata in the northeastern region of India (Fig.
Nodostoma viridipenne
Motschulsky, 1860:
Nodostoma frontale:
Nodostoma occipitale:
Nodostoma haroldi:
Nodostoma aeneipenne:
Nodostoma haroldi var. apicipes:
Basilepta viridipenne:
Basilepta viridipennis:
Basilepta occipitalis:
Type material
of Nodostoma occipitale Jacoby: 62590/ Type (red bordered circular label)/ Doherty/ Tenesserim, Mergui/ Fry Coll. 1905-100/ Nodostoma occipitale Jac., Type (blue label)” (
Basilepta viridipennis (Fig.
India, Nepal, Myanmar (= Burma), Thailand, Laos, Vietnam, Hainan, Malaya, Sumatra.
Alticini
Eucycla varipes
Jacoby, 1884:
Sphaeroderma varipes:
Bhamoina varipes:
Bhamonia
[sic] varipes:
Sphaeroderma varipennis
Type material
of Sphaeroderma varipennis Jacoby: “Type (H.T.) (red bordered circular label)/ Carin Cheba, 900–1100 m, L. Fea, v.XII.88 / Jacoby Coll. 1909-28a / Sphaerod. varipennis Jac. (blue label)” (
The genus Bhamoina closely resembles Sphaeroderma (see below for the generic diagnosis of Sphaeroderma). Bhamoina acutangula (Jacoby), the type species of the genus, was originally described in Sphaeroderma. Bhamoina can be easily separated from Sphaeroderma by the anteriorly produced anterolateral corners of pronotum (in Sphaeroderma, the anterolateral corners of pronotum are not produced forward, or only slightly produced). Sphaeroderma varipennis Jacoby, treated as a synonym of B. varipes by
Entirely red-brown (Fig.
Length 2.71–3.41 mm, width 1.97–2.80 mm, 1.34× longer than broad. In lateral view vertex weakly convex, forming a concavity where it joins frons; frons strongly arched, joining clypeus at an obtuse angle. In frontal view vertex moderately flat, sparsely punctate with a mixture of small and minute punctures. Supraorbital pore circular, without shallow groove surrounding it, placed just above orbital sulcus, two or three smaller punctures anterior to supraorbital pore present. In frontal view (Fig.
Pronotum (Fig.
Scutellum triangular, acutely angulate posteriorly, shiny, flat on top, minutely punctate. Elytra as wide as pronotum at base, widened postbasally, lateral margin entirely visible in dorsal view. Elytral apex convex. Elytral punctures confused in mesal half, tend to form rows in lateral half, outermost punctures forming a regular row. Each elytral puncture surrounded by a dark halo, distance between adjacent punctures less than diameter of one puncture, including dark halo.
Maximum width of elytral epipleura subequal to that of midfemur. Epipleura subhorizontal, visible in lateral view, widest at proximal one-fourth, gradually narrowing till distal one-third and then abruptly narrowed, hardly reaching apex. Prosternum gently depressed on top, setose, coarsely but shallowly punctate; minimum distance from anterior margin of prosternum to coxal cavity less than half of minimum width of prosternal intercoxal process; prosternal intercoxal process longer than wide, narrowed in middle, widened apically, posterior margin concave. Mesosternum transverse, nearly three times wider than long, with concave posterior margin; metasternum profusely setose medially, coarsely punctate. First abdominal ventrite profusely setose medially, coarsely punctate; in length, medially subequal to next three combined. Last ventrite a little longer than preceding two combined. Last visible tergite medially with a broad longitudinal groove not reaching apex.
Foretibia without apical spine. Mid- and hind tibiae with apical spine. First pro-, meso-, and metatarsomeres distinctly wider in male than in female; with capitate setae ventrally in male and pointed setae in female. Posterior margin of last ventrite entire in female; forms a lobe notched on either side, in middle in male. Last ventrite internally with a longitudinal apodeme along mid-line in male (Fig.
Male genitalia with aedeagus in lateral view (Fig.
Female genitalia with spermathecal receptacle (Fig.
Adults feed on the abaxial surface of the leaf lamina, making transverse, narrow linear scars. Feeding by Basilepta subcostata results in much shorter and broader feeding troughs, which is very different from that of Bhamoina varipes.
India (Assam; Meghalaya; Uttarakhand (Dehra Dun)); Myanmar; Nepal (
Unidentified species of Sphaeroderma Stephens have been reported from Laos as defoliators of banana (
Small to medium sized flea beetles, convex and broadly oval. Red brown to black with or without spots or stripes on elytra. Head hypognathous, frontal ridge raised, forming T-shaped ridge with apical margin of head capsule. Antennal calli well delineated by sulci, supracallinal sulcus deep. Pronotum broader than long, without impressions or furrows. Posterior margin bisinuate with a lobe in middle. Procoxal cavity open behind. Anterolateral corners of pronotum not greatly produced forward. Metatibia dorsally flat or concave, with lateral and mesal margins forming ridge. Third tarsomere broad, its anterior margin entire, not bilobed. First metatarsomere short, not longer than next two combined. Intercoxal part of first abdominal ventrite truncate. Vaginal palpi broader than long.
Holotype
: ♂: India: Meghalaya: Barapani, 25°41'17.6"N, 91°55'5.1"E; 5.vi.2013, 993 m; Prathapan K D Coll., Ex Banana (
This species closely resembles S. mandarensis Jacoby (
Entirely red-brown (Fig.
Maxillary palpi with four palpomeres, penultimate palpomere being thicker and longer than last palpomere. First palpomere smallest, second subequal to last. Labial palpi three-segmented with the second palpomere thicker than last, subequal to last in length. Proportionate length of antennomeres I to XI: 1 : 0.61 : 0.57 : 0.61 : 0.74 : 0.70 : 0.74 : 0.70 : 0.70 : 0.70 : 1.09.
Pronotum (Fig.
Scutellum as broad as long, obtusely narrowed posteriorly, surface very minutely punctate. Elytra as broad as pronotum at basal margin, widening near humerus. Humerus convex, weakly depressed posteriorly. Elytra with a mixture of small and large punctures. Punctures confused, tend to form uncountable rows. Lateral most row regular, followed by one or two countable adjacent rows. Distance between adjacent punctures smaller than diameter of a puncture. Elytral apex convex. Maximum width of epipleura at anterior one-third; subequal to forefemur in width. Epipleura subhorizontal, narrowing posterior to anterior one-third, not reaching elytral apex.
Prosternum widened posteriorly, posterior margin concave medially, slightly depressed on top, setose with coarse shallow punctures. Mesosternum setose, transverse, with concave posterior margin. Metasternum with moderate sized, deep punctures, thickly setose on either side. First abdominal ventrite longest, 2–4 each shorter than fifth separately; fifth longer than preceding two combined, shorter than preceding three combined. Last visible tergite with a shallow groove along middle, not reaching apex. All tibiae with apical spine.
First pro-, meso-, and metatarsomeres slightly wider with capitate setae ventrally in male. In female, all first tarsomeres ventrally with pointed setae. Posterior margin of last ventrite entire in female, forms a lobe notched on either side in middle in male. Last ventrite internally with a longitudinal apodeme along mid-line in male (Fig.
Male genitalia (Fig.
Female genitalia with spermathecal receptacle (Fig.
The specific epithet is a Latin adjective in nominative case in reference to the reddish colour of this species.
India (Meghalaya).
Adults feed on the foliage of banana (Musa spp.).
1 | Form oblong-oval, metallic red and blue or entirely reddish, dark green, or blue (Fig. |
Basilepta subcostata (Jacoby) |
– | Form elongate-oval, entirely reddish to dark reddish brown, not metallic. Antennal calli well developed, delimited by deep sulci. Lateral margins of pronotum curved, not angulate. Elytra without a lateral ridge/costa. Forecoxal cavities open behind. Hind femora greatly enlarged compared to fore- and midfemora, tibiae preapically not emarginate, without a ventral tooth | 2 |
2 | Form broad oval, reddish to dark reddish brown (Fig. |
Bhamoina varipes (Jacoby) |
– | Form more elongate and less robust, entirely reddish (Fig. |
Sphaeroderma cruenta Prathapan & Kumari, sp. nov. |
In total 10 COI sequences of B. subcostata (six from Assam and four from Uttar Pradesh) were deposited in GenBank and accession numbers obtained (KY908365.1, MK414475.1, MK414474.1, MK414473.1, MK414472.1, K414470.1, MK414469.1, MK414468.1, MK414467.1 and MK414466.1). The pairwise nucleotide sequence identity of COI sequences of B. subcostata from Assam and Uttar Pradesh ranged from 98 to 100%, indicating that they were conspecific. The phylogenetic tree constructed by the maximum likelihood method based on COI gene sequence alignments revealed two clusters, with B. subcostata from Assam and UP forming one cluster (Group I), and the sequences from the outgroup taxa falling in another cluster (Group II) (Fig.
Maximum Likelihood phylogeny of B. subcostata populations from Assam and Uttar Pradesh, India. The evolutionary history was inferred by using the Maximum Likelihood method and Tamura-Nei model. The tree with the highest log likelihood (-3489.32) is shown. The percentage of trees in which the associated taxa clustered together is shown next to the branches. Initial tree(s) for the heuristic search were obtained automatically by applying Neighbor-Join and BioNJ algorithms to a matrix of pairwise distances estimated using the Maximum Composite Likelihood (MCL) approach, and then selecting the topology with superior log likelihood value. The tree is drawn to scale, with branch lengths measured in the number of substitutions per site. This analysis involved 16 nucleotide sequences. Codon positions included were 1st+2nd+3rd+Noncoding. There was a total of 660 positions in the final dataset. Evolutionary analyses were conducted in MEGA X.
The chrysomelids recorded by us on banana here are also included in the host plants listed by
It is noteworthy that three species of chrysomelids belonging to two systematically distant subfamilies (Galerucinae and Eumolpinae) are feeding on the same host plant. More studies are needed to determine the nature and extent of damage to bananas caused by B. varipes and S. cruenta sp. nov. and to clarify their distribution in India, as they are not common pests. Taro (Colacasia esculenta L.) has been recorded as a host plant of B. subcostata [as “Nodostoma subcostatum”] in West Bengal (
Although Basilepta subcostata is known to be a serious pest of bananas and plantains in the northeastern, eastern, and northern regions of India, there is no published record of its occurrence in any part of peninsular India. However, two specimens collected on banana from Vittal, Karnataka (South India), and one specimen from “Deccan” were examined by JP in the collections of the Natural History Museum, London. These specimens indicate that this pest is present in peninsular India albeit in very small numbers and highlights the importance of museum collections in determining the geographic range of economically important insect pests. Its occurrence in peninsular India is a major concern for banana growers, and it is essential to conduct more systematic surveys to acquire data on the extent of its presence there. Plant protection workers and applied entomologists in peninsular India need to be alerted about the presence of B. subcostata, as it is virtually unknown in peninsular India, although it has a huge potential to cause devastation. Management options for B. subcostata mainly involve removal of grassy weeds, application of insecticides, neem-based biopesticides, entomofungal pathogens like Beauveria bassiana, and covering fruit bunches with polythene sleeves (
It is a matter of concern that systematic revisions of pests and related species important in agriculture and horticulture are lacking in biodiversity-rich countries like India, as well as the rest of Asia, and even for cash crops like banana. The International Plant Protection Convention (IPPC) stipulates that contracting parties should “conduct surveillance for pests and develop and maintain adequate information on pest status in order to support categorization of pests, and for the development of appropriate phytosanitary measures” (
We thank Dr S. Uma, Director, ICAR-National Research Centre for Banana, Trichy, for the facilities and support in carrying out this work. The second author gratefully acknowledges the Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard University, Massachusetts, for enabling her visit to Natural History Museum, London, funded by an Ernst Mayr travel grant and Dr Max Barclay, Dr Michael Geiser, and Dr Keita Matsumoto of the Natural History Museum, London, for facilitating the study and imaging of type material of Chrysomelidae. We thank the Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin, for waiving the fees for publishing this paper. We are grateful to Dr Elisabeth Geiser and an anonymous reviewer for their thorough and constructive reviews which greatly helped in improving the manuscript.