Research Article |
Corresponding author: Josip Skejo ( skejo.josip@gmail.com ) Corresponding author: Niko Kasalo ( niko.kasalo5@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Claudia Hemp
© 2023 Josip Skejo, Sheyla Yong, Domagoj Bogić, Niko Kasalo.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Skejo J, Yong S, Bogić D, Kasalo N (2023) Caribbean pygmy jumping leaves (Tetrigidae, Cladonotinae, Choriphyllini). Deutsche Entomologische Zeitschrift 70(1): 129-141. https://doi.org/10.3897/dez.70.98982
|
The tribe Choriphyllini Cadena-Castañeda & Silva, 2019 consists of only two genera, Choriphyllum Serville, 1838 and Phyllotettix Hancock, 1902b, combining leaf-like Caribbean wide-nosed pygmy grasshoppers (Tetrigidae, Cladonotinae). The genus Choriphyllum has four species, C. bahamense Perez-Gelabert & Otte, 1999 from the Bahamas (Hummingbird Cay Island), and C. sagrai Serville, 1838, C. saussurei Bolívar, 1887 and C. wallaceum Skejo, Kasalo & Yong, sp. nov. from Cuba. The gender of C. bahamensis is changed to C. bahamense in order to match the grammatical gender of the genus, which is neuter. Silva’s designation of C. sagrai, the type species of Choriphyllum, as nomen dubium in 2019 was incorrect as Serville’s drawing clearly points to this species, endemic to Cuba, so nothing about its identity is doubtful. The genus Phyllotettix is endemic to Jamaica, where four species live: P. rhombeus (Felton, 1765), P. foliatus (Hancock, 1902a), P. compressus (Thunberg, 1815) and P. plagiatus (Walker, 1871), comb. nov. of Choriphyllum plagiatum. Choriphyllum westwoodi Hancock, 1902a, syn. nov. is synonymous with Phyllotettix rhombeus and not with P. compressus. A new subgenus is established, Phyllotettix (Rhombotettix) subgen. nov. for P. (R.) plagiatus comb. nov. and P. (R.) rhombeus. A new species complex, Phyllotettix (compressus) sp. complex nov. is established for two morphologically close species, P. compressus, and P. foliatus; while another new species complex, Choriphyllum (sagrai) sp. complex nov. includes C. sagrai and C. wallaceum sp. nov. An annotated key to genera, subgenera, species groups and species is provided.
Alfred Russel Wallace, Bahamas, complex, Choriphyllum, Cuba, iNaturalist, Jamaica, new species, Phyllotettix, revision, species group, subgenus, synonym
Wide-nosed pygmy grasshoppers (Tetrigidae, Cladonotinae) include species of rather unique morphology, but their taxonomy was pretty chaotic till recently (
The tribe Choriphyllini was established recently (
Original descriptions (
The measurements were made using the ImageJ (v. 1.53t) software (
For each genus, we propose a vernacular name, list synonyms and type species and present composition, distribution and a brief generic diagnosis. For the new subgenus, we designate the type species, propose vernacular names and present composition, distribution and brief diagnoses. We define a species group as a category containing species with many similarities, but also with enough differences that make synonymisation impractical without more evidence; the specific status of each species is preserved and their close relationships are reflected by the groupings. For each species group, we propose a vernacular name and provide annotated distribution data and a brief diagnosis. For each species, we propose a vernacular name, present detailed taxonomic and nomenclatural history, information on type specimens and new records, annotated distribution data and a brief diagnosis.
Museum abbreviations are listed as follows:
BMNH The Natural History Museum [British Museum of Natural History], London, UK;
FZ Fernando de Zayas private collection (formerly at Havana, Cuba, current whereabouts unknown);
IES Instituto de Ecología y Sistemática, La Habana, Cuba;
MNHNC Museo Nacional de Historia Natural Cubana, Havana, Cuba;
OSF Orthoptera Species File; SY – Personal collection of Sheyla Yong, Havana, Cuba;
Family Tetrigidae Rambur, 1838
Subfamily Cladonotinae Bolívar, 1887
Choriphyllum Serville, 1838, type species C. sagrai Serville, 1838.
(Figs
= Chloriphyllum Scudder, 1869.
= Chorophyllum Fieber, 1845.
Choriphyllum sagrai Serville, 1838.
(Figs
(Figs
Annotated schematic pictorial key to genera and species of Choriphyllini. Specimens are not to scale; for size comparison see Fig.
Choriphyllum bahamensis
Perez-Gelabert & Otte, 1999: 454 (original description and type drawings);
The Bahamas: B. W. I. Exuma: Hummingbird Cay W of Georgetown (
Holotype. The Bahamas • 1 ♂; Exuma: Hummingbird Cay W of Georgetown; 12 Jun 1968; B. K. Dozier leg.;
(Fig.
(Figs
Comparative measurements of the Choriphyllini members. Measurements shown in the brackets were taken from the type specimen drawings. Note the huge size of Phyllotettix rhombeus pronotum. Abbreviations HT – holotype, PT – paratype, ST – syntype.
Species and specimen | Body length | Pronotal length | Pronotal height | Hind femur length |
---|---|---|---|---|
Genus Choriphyllum | ||||
C. bahamense, HT♀ | 10.0 mm | 12.3 mm | 7.1 mm | 6.1 mm |
C. bahamense, PT ♀ | 10.1 mm | 13.6 mm | 7.9 mm | 6.6 mm |
C. bahamense, PT ♂ | 10.0 mm | 11.9 mm | 6.9 mm | 5.7 mm |
C. (sagrai) sp. complex nov. | ||||
C. (s.) sagrai, HT♀ | (10.8 mm) | 18.0 mm | (11.0 mm) | (6.0 mm) |
C. (s.) sagrai, GUNDLACH ♀ | 9.9 mm | 20.50 mm | 12.9 mm | 7.7 mm |
C. (s.) wallaceum sp. nov HT ♂ | 10.7 mm | 16.05 mm | 9.5 mm | 6.4 mm |
C. saussurei, ST♀ | 10.0 mm | 13.0 mm | 6.7 mm | 6.0 mm |
C. saussurei, ST♀ | 8.9 mm | 12.0 mm | 6.2 mm | 6.0 mm |
C. saussurei, GUNDLACH ♀ | 8.1 mm | 130 mm | 7.4 mm | 5.7 mm |
Genus Phyllotettix | ||||
Subgenus Phyllotettix | ||||
P. (P.) (compressus) sp. complex nov. | ||||
P. (P.) (c.) compressus, HT♂ | 12.1 mm | 16.0 mm | 11.2 mm | 8.6 mm |
P. (c.) foliatus, HT♀ | 16.0 mm | 19.0 mm | (12.1 mm) | 9.0 mm |
P. (c.) foliatus, NMW♀ | 16.7 mm | 21.7 mm | 16.9 mm | 9.7 mm |
P. (c.) foliatus, NMW♂ | 13.8 mm | 18.6 mm | 13.4 mm | 8.6 mm |
Subgenus Rhombotettix | ||||
P. (R.) rhombeus, HT♀ | 16.2 mm | 28.8 mm | 17.9 mm | 11.0 mm |
P. (R.) plagiatus, HT♂ | 11.6 mm | 17.4 mm | 11.1 mm | 7.5 mm |
See Table
The complex includes two morphologically similar species, C. sagrai and C. wallaceum sp. nov., endemic to Cuba.
(Figs
Choriphyllum sagrai Serville, 1838: 755 (description, type locality Cuba, holotype drawing). Taxonomic and nomenclatural history.
Hymenotes sagrai
Serville;
Hymenotes sagrai
Westw.;
Hymenotes sagrae
Serville;
Choriphyllum sagrae
Serv.;
Phyllonotus sagrai
Serv.;
Choriphyllum sagrai
Serville;
Cuba, without specified location (
Type specimen likely deposited at
Cuba • 3 ♀; Pinar del Río Province, Viñales Municipality; 22 May 2015; R. Teruel and T. M. Rodríguez-Cabrera leg.; SY. (Figs
Cuba • 1♀ Gundlach leg.; MNHNC.
Cuba • 3 ♀; Artemisa Province, Sierra del Rosario, Rancho Mundito; 4 Jun 1947; F. de Zayas and J. Ferrás leg.; FZ.
Cuba • 1; Pinar del Río Province, Guane Municipality, Paredones; Aug 1969; F. de Zayas leg.; FZ.
Cuba • 4♀, 3♂, 1; Artemisa Province, Sierra Rangel; Jul-Aug 1930; Hermano Roberto leg.; on leaf litter in coffee plantation; IES.
Cuba • 1♂; Artemisa Province, Sierra Rangel, las Ánimas; 1,500 ft. (457 m) a.s.l.; May. 1933; Bruner and Otero leg.; IES.
Cuba • 1; Artemisa Province, Sierra Rangel; 5 Sep 1934; Bruner and Otero leg.; IES.
Cuba • 1♀; Artemisa Province, San Cristóbal Municipality, Aspiro; Mar 1955; P. Alayo leg.; IES.
(Fig.
(Figs
The identity of the species is not questionable (See Figs
See Table
“Choriphyllum seoanei”, not published “new species” by Bolívar (
Named after Alfred Russel Wallace, the father of biogeography, modern evolutionary thought and a contributor to many fields of biology. The species name is a neuter gender adjective, second Latin declension, derived from Wallace, i.e. wallaceus, wallacea, wallaceum. The specific epithet celebrates the 200th anniversary of Alfred Russel Wallace birth (8 January 1823).
Cuba, no specific location/s known.
Holotype
of Choriphyllum wallaceum Skejo, Kasalo & Yong, sp. nov. Cuba • 1 ♂; No specified locality, labels under the specimen: 1st handwritten by Bolívar “Chor. Seoanei Bol Typo. Cuba (Seoane)”, 2nd label printed by París “especie no publicada”, 3rd label handwritten by Skejo “Choriphyllum cf. sagrai det. Skejo X.2018.”, 4th label is the catalogue number printed by
(Fig.
(Figs
Head. Same as in other members of the tribe. Convex bulging vertex, frontal costa forks into a wide scutellum below half the height of the eye, upper margins of antennal grooves at the level of the bottom margin of the eyes.
Pronotum. General shape close to that observed in C. sagrai, but visibly more angular. The highest region of the pronotal crest is above the humeral angles and is shaped as a slanted plateau (rounded in C. sagrai). Anterior to the highest point, the crest slopes down with barely perceptible undulations (a long, but shallow depression present in C. sagrai). Posterior to the highest point, the crest slopes down with slight undulations (one well-expressed convexity in C. sagrai).
Legs. Anterior femora a little expanded proximally, bearing a tubercle at the middle of the ventral margin. Middle femora with slightly undulated margins, ventral margin with a slight tubercle at the distal third of its length. Hind femora robust, dorsal margin elevated in the anterior half and sloping down towards the knee; one moderate protrusion before the antegenicular tooth. Antegenicular tooth moderately expressed, genicular tooth strongly expressed. Legs are generally rougher than in C. sagrai.
The diagnostic description presented here implies that the diagnostic criteria of higher taxa that encompass this species apply as well and are, thus, considered sufficient to differentiate C. wallaceum sp. nov. from other species.
See Table
Choriphyllum saussurei
Bolívar, 1887: 203–204 (original description, type locality Cuba, and holotype drawing);
Phyllonotus saussurei
Bol.;
Choriphyllum saussurei
Bolívar;
Cuba, without a specified location (
Syntype. ♀ Cuba • Gundlach leg.; MNHNC.; Syntypes. Cuba • 2♀ M. H. de Saussure leg.
Cuba • 1 ♂; Sierra del Grillo; Apr 1969; P. Alayo leg.; IES.
Cuba • 1 ♀; Mayabeque Province, Jaruco Municipality, Escaleras de Jaruco; 9 Apr 1979; J. de la Cruz leg.; IES.
Cuba • 1 ♀; Isla de la Juventud Especial Municipality, Isla de Pinos, Punta del Este; 19 May 1974; L. F. de Armas leg.; IES.
(Fig.
(Figs
See Table
= Phyllonotus Hancock, 1902a (preoccupied with Phyllonotus Swainson, 1833, Mollusca).
= Zaphyllonotum Caudell, 1909 (type species Choriphyllum foliatum Hancock = Phyllotettix foliatus).
Acrydium compressum Thunberg, 1815 (= Phyllotettix compressus).
(Figs
(Figs
Acrydium compressum Thunberg, 1815
(Figs
(Figs
(Figs
(Figs
Acrydium compressum
Thunberg, 1815: 162 (description);
Hymenotes compressus
Thunb.;
Acridium compressum
Thunb.;
Phyllotettix Compressa
Thunb.;
Phyllotettix compressus
Thunberg;
Phyllotettix westwoodi
Hancock;
Jamaica, without specified location (
Hancock’s plate I from the “Tettigidae of North America” shows leaf-like Caribbean species under the numbers 1), 2) and 7), but has many taxonomic and nomenclatural errors. 1) – Phyllotettix foliatus (= female holotype of Hancock’s Choriphyllum foliatum), 2) – Phyllotettix rhombeus (= Hancock’s Choriphyllum westwoodi), 7) – Choriphyllum saussurei. (= Hancock’s Phyllonotus saussurei). Source: Biodiversity Heritage Library, available at https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/25899#page/10.
The evidence of synonymy of Choriphyllum westwoodi Hancock, 1902a with Phyllotettix rhombeus (Felton, 1965); A.
Holotype
♂ of Acridium compressum. Jamaica • 1 ♂;
Jamaica • 1 ♀; Blue Mountains; 18.054489°N, 76.600555°W; 14 May 2022; Damany Calder leg.; iNaturalist ID: 117405730. Four photographs are available at https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/117405730).
Jamaica • 1 ♀;
(Fig.
(Figs
See Table
Choriphyllum foliatum Hancock, 1902a: Plate I, (fig. 1), 42 (description, holotype drawing); Otte, D. 1979[1978]:38 (status of the types).
Phyllotettix foliatus
Hancock, 1907: 12 (new combination, listed in the catalogue);
Zaphyllonotum foliatum Caudell, 1909:113 (mentioned in a new combination, type species of Zaphyllonotum).
Jamaica, without specified locality (
Holotype
♀ of Choriphyllum foliatum. Jamaica • 1 ♀;
Jamaica • 1 ♂; Blue Mountains, Hardwar Gap; 8 Dec 1925; C. W. O’Brien leg.; “feeding on lichens on tree trunks at night”; NMW. Photographs at the OSF, http://orthoptera.speciesfile.org/Common/basic/Taxa.aspx?TaxonNameID=1100602.
(Fig.
(Figs
See Table
Cicada rhombea Felton, 1765 = Phyllotettix (Rhombotettix) rhombeus.
Rhombotettix is a noun of masculine gender made up of combining Latinised Ancient Greek words for rhombus (ῥόμβος, rhombos) and grasshopper (τέττιξ, tettix). This name was selected because of its prosody in the combination with the specific epitheton of the type species, “rhombeus”.
(Figs
(Figs
Choriphyllum plagiatum
Walker, 1871: 845 (original description);
Phyllonotus plagiatum Hancock, 1902: 45–46 (included in the key, brief re-description).
Jamaica, without specified locality (
Holotype of Choriphyllum plagiatum. Jamaica • 1 ♂; BMNH. Photograph on the OSF, http://orthoptera.speciesfile.org/Common/basic/Taxa.aspx?TaxonNameID=1100630.
(Fig.
(Figs
See Table
Cicada rhombea Felton, 1765: 55 (original description and holotype drawing). Taxonomic and nomenclatural history.
Cicada rhombea
Backer.;
Membracis rhombea
Linn.;
Hymenotes rhombea
Fabricius;
Hymenotes rhombea
Felton;
Acridium (Hymenotes) rhombeum
Baker.;
Hymenotes rhombea
Westw.;
Choriphyllum rhombeum
Baker;
Choriphyllum rhombeum
Walk.;
Choriphyllum rhombeum
L.;
Choriphyllum westwoodi
Hancock, 1902a: Plate I (fig. 2), 42, 44 (included in the key, short re-description) (Note: even though Choriphyllum westwoodi was aimed to be a replacement name for Acrydium compressum, the type specimen on which the new name was based belongs to Phyllotettix rhombeus) syn. nov. (Figs
Phyllotettix rhombeus
(Baker.),
Phyllotettix rhombea
Linn;
Phyllotettix westwoodi
Hancock.;
Zaphyllonotum westwoodi Hancock; Caudel 1909: 113 (mentioned as a new combination of Choriphyllum compressum).
Phyllotettix rhombeus
(Linnaeus, 1767)
Phyllotettix rhombeus
(Felton, 1765)
Jamaica, without specified locality (
Holotype of Cicada rhombea. Jamaica • 1 ♀; BMNH. Photograph on the OSF, http://orthoptera.speciesfile.org/Common/basic/Taxa.aspx?TaxonNameID=1100605.
Holotype
♀ of Choriphyllum westwoodi (plate 1, fig. 2 in
(Fig.
(Figs
See Table
See schematic pictorial key, Fig.
1A | Anterior margin of pronotum smooth. Capital sinus long, deep, and narrow. Highest point of pronotum in the middle or before the middle. Posterior tip of pronotum truncated. Cuba, the Bahamas | genus Choriphyllum 2 |
1B | Anterior margin of pronotum undulated. Highest point of pronotum behind the middle. Capital sinus short, shallow and wide. Posterior tip of pronotum oblique or sharp. Jamaica | genus Phyllotettix 4 |
2A | Tip of pronotum reaching the tips of the hind knees and excised in a straight fashion. The Bahamas, Hummingbird Cay Isl | Choriphyllum bahamense |
2B | Posterior margin of the pronotum in lateral view with one large undulation in the middle | Choriphyllum saussurei |
2C | Posterior margin of the pronotum in lateral view straight or semi-circular, without a notable undulation in the middle | Choriphyllum (sagrai) 3 |
3A | In lateral view, pronotum more rounded, posterior margin of pronotum semicircular | Choriphyllum (sagrai) sagrai |
3B | In lateral view, pronotum more angular, posterior margin of pronotum straight | Choriphyllum (sagrai) wallaceum sp. nov. |
4A | Posterior margin of pronotal crest excised and/or convex in lateral view. Pronotum caudally does not reach behind the hind knees | Subgenus Phyllotettix 5 |
4B | Posterior margin of pronotal crest obliquely projected and undulated in lateral view. Pronotum caudally reaches behind the hind knees | Rhombotettix subgen. nov. 6 |
5A | Highest point of pronotum narrow and sharp and after it, the posterior margin of the pronotum strongly convex | Phyllotettix (Phyllotettix) (compressus) compressus |
5B | Highest point of pronotum wide and oblique and after it, the posterior margin of pronotum truncated or weakly convex | Phyllotettix (P.) (compressus) foliatus |
6A | The most produced anterior part of the pronotum is not the one above the head, but the one above it. Pronotal crest rectangular in lateral view. Pronotum length > 25 mm | Phyllotettix (Rhombotettix) rhombeus |
6B | The most produced anterior part of the pronotum is just above the head. The pronotal crest is triangular in lateral view. Pronotum length < 20 mm | Phyllotettix (R.) plagiatus comb. nov. |
Phyllotettix (Rhombotettix) rhombeus (Felton, 1765), a species first assigned to Cicada (
The Jamaican Colossal Jumping Leaf indeed is a “colossus”. Its pronotal length reaches almost 3 cm and its height reaches almost 2 cm, making it the unrivalled world’s largest Tetrigidae species known to date. The second largest is the Malagasy Holocerus devriesei, with a pronotum length of a little bit more than 2.5 cm (
We assembled measurements by comparing those obtained from museum specimens with
All the members of the tribe Choriphyllini are reviewed and a new subgenus (Rhombotettix subgen. nov.), new species groups/complexes (Phyllotettix (P.) (compressus) sp. complex nov.; Choriphyllum (sagrai) sp. complex nov.) and a new combination (Phyllotettix (Rhombotettix) plagiatus comb. nov.) are proposed in order to try to reflect the evolutionary history of this interesting taxon, as observed from morphological similarity. The species complex was established in order to clearly point out that the species included in it share many morphological characteristics and have extremely small differences, so it is not clear whether they have separate evolutionary histories.
Choriphyllum sagrai is not a nomen dubium (
The newly-described species and the existence of Choriphyllum bahamense on the tiny and low island of Hummingbird Cay in the Bahamas imply that more Choriphyllum species are to be found in the future. The huge diversity of Phyllotettix in Jamaica, based on a few specimens only, provides even stronger evidence that we are still in the very beginning of understanding the Caribbean Pygmy Jumping Leaves.
Is the Phyllotettix (Phyllotettix) (compressus) complex only a single species or two or three closely related species? We can only speculate from four museum specimens, a drawing and a photograph of a living individual. Hence, at this moment, synonymisation or new species establishment would not bring any solution, but instead, introduce more chaos into an already loosely founded system. For Phyllotettix (Rhombotettix) plagiatus comb. nov. and P. (R.) rhombeus little can be said, as the holotypes, unfortunately, remain the only specimens from which information can be extracted.
The long history of this small tribe illustrates how mistakes accumulate when there is a lack of material which is badly handled as well. Previous authors did not all have the means to carefully examine the material or were unaware of its existence, leading to confusing synonymies (e.g.
A lot of the crucial information on the Caribbean pygmy jumping leaves is still lacking, despite the two-and-a-half-century-long research tradition (from
Citizen scientists in the Caribbean should be encouraged to collect observations of these grasshoppers and consequently, the citizen science platforms, such as iNaturalist, should be regularly monitored by scientists in order to establish and maintain a continuous research practice. Such practice is already proven to work (e.g.
The aim of future research should be collecting more specimens, so our hypotheses on the species and their positions may be tested. Museum collections should be investigated as well to see whether there are more undocumented species/specimens. Fieldwork in the Caribbean region is necessary. Only fresh samples may provide a predisposition for the next step, an evolutionary study by means of molecular phylogeny. By bringing these charismatic critters to public attention and making their identification easier, we hope to foster a wider interest in them.
We are thankful to everyone who took photos of a Choriphyllini members, allowing us to study their taxonomy and biogeography. Thank you to Mercedes Paris from the